/sostav-comments — draft replies to the fresh club shortlist (the owner's voice, draft-first)

Why. When the owner goes through the fresh nightly shortlist, he usually wants ready-made draft replies for the interesting club threads. This skill does it in one pass: read the detector report → pick the safe posts → write short answers in his voice → show them. It sends nothing — the owner copies whatever he likes.

The main rules:

• Draft-first, never publishes. The skill only writes drafts into the chat. Posting into the club is done by the owner, by hand.
• Safe-topic gate. Draft only in opinion/knowledge threads (Knowledge, Lectures, Business, Investing, Travel, Health, General-on-topic). ⛔ NEVER draft in the Crypto / Dating / Off-topic-flood threads, or in any grey-financial or personal thread — those are data, not a place to reply.
• Short text, tone set by the channel ([[short-text-when-unreviewed]]): a meaningful answer in messenger register (not a 5-word Facebook joke — here you need context and knowledge of who the person is; pull the person-sostav-* card if the member is a ⭐).
• The owner's voice (Opus). No "positioned" replies, no showing off. On topic, to the point, without making someone else's announcement about yourself.
• Anti-leak ([[reglament-anti-leak-na-vyhode]]): drafts stay in the private layer; nothing sensitive from the club leaks into other channels.

---

0. A fresh shortlist

The latest detector report:

ls $IMPORTS_ROOT/alpha\candidates\sostav-*-report.md   # take the newest one by date

If there is none / it is stale — refresh the corpus first (the nightly path): python $IMPORTS_ROOT/sostav\nightly_run.py (idempotent, it backfills).

1. Pick the posts worth answering

From the shortlist keep only those where:

• the topic is safe (see the gate above);
• the post is an opinion/question/piece of knowledge where a meaningful answer belongs (not an announcement, not an intro, not a grey request);
• a ⭐ author → open $OBSIDIAN_VAULT/07-People\person-sostav-<slug>.md for the "who is this" context.

2. A grounding snippet (when it helps)

If the answer benefits from specifics (a quote/fact/example), take a relevant chunk from the working corpus — the YouTube Data API (the only pool that still works; the social networks are behind login walls), via $IMPORTS_ROOT/sostav\daily_safe_fetch.py (safe-only gate). Lift 1-2 fragments verbatim; don't paraphrase.

3. The drafts (Opus, personal, all different)

For each selected post — a separate short answer in the owner's voice. Assemble the batch:

1. [Knowledge · Author X] post: "…the claim…"
   → draft: "…a meaningful, on-topic answer in the owner's voice…"
2. ...

Different texts, on topic, no template. Voice quality ≥ Opus ([[content-Mei-style]] — an influence, not a copy).

4. Hand it to the owner

Show the batch of drafts in the chat + note which ⭐ contacts you pulled cards for. Stop there — the owner sends them himself.

---

Stop valves

• ⛔ Post/send nothing — drafts into the chat only.
• ⛔ Don't draft in grey/personal/crypto threads (the safe gate).
• ⛔ Nothing from the club leaks into other channels ([[reglament-anti-leak-na-vyhode]]).
• Money/commitments/secrets inside a draft → cut them, that is Tier-2.

Related

• Detector / nightly path: $IMPORTS_ROOT/sostav\nightly_run.py, sostav_alpha.py.
• The reply corpus: daily_safe_fetch.py (YouTube Data API, secrets/youtube.env).
• Voice: [[short-text-when-unreviewed]], [[content-Mei-style]], /speak-as.
• Sibling skills: /fb-reply (Facebook comments), /mine-channel, /alpha-judge.
• Canon: memory sostav-community-import, [[reglament-anti-leak-na-vyhode]].

<!--kit-footer-->

---

Like this skill? It is one of 100 in second-brain-starter-kit: the second brain we built for ourselves and run every day at Palo Alto AI Research Lab. Install the whole set with npx skills add tonydzi/second-brain-starter-kit. Everything is open source and free, so take what you need.

Flagships worth a look on their own: secondop-panel (a second opinion from a panel of external models), claude-memory-tidy (stop your agent's memory from rotting), telegram-mcp-kit (your own Telegram over MCP in about 15 minutes).

Author: Anton Dziatkovskii, Palo Alto AI Research Lab. Telegram @tonydzi - WhatsApp +1 341 222 9178 - X @Tony_Stef_

Engineers: want to test-drive this setup? Message me. I hand out free starter seeds to engineers who test and report back, and custom skill requests are welcome.