User Perspective (USR)

Evaluates how well the project communicates its purpose and value to users, contributors, and integrators. Assigns a score from 0.0 to 1.0 across three dimensions.

Dimensions

README quality — Can someone discover and use this project?

• Missing README = 0.0
• Score = min(readmeLength / 2000, 1.0) — 2000+ chars = full score
• A thin README (<500 chars) generates a high-priority task

Description — Is the package self-describing?

• If no package.json exists, marked N/A (not applicable to non-npm projects)
• If package.json exists: non-empty description field = 1.0, missing or empty = 0.0

Changelog — Is the release history communicated?

• CHANGELOG.md or CHANGELOG present = 1.0
• Missing = 0.5 (partial credit — not critical)

Scoring

usr_score = (readme + description + changelog) / 3

Score interpretation:

• 0.9–1.0 Well-documented and discoverable
• 0.7–0.9 Good documentation with minor gaps
• 0.5–0.7 Documentation is present but thin — a new user would struggle
• 0.0–0.5 Project is effectively undiscoverable — documentation is a blocker

Tasks Generated

Finding	Priority
No README.md	critical
README < 500 chars	high
No package.json description (when package.json exists)	medium

Agent Analysis Guide

When performing a manual USR analysis:

1. Read the README as if you are a new user — can you answer: what is this, how do I install it, how do I use it?
2. Check for usage examples with real commands or code snippets (not just API reference)
3. If package.json exists: verify the description field accurately describes what the package does in one line; if no package.json, mark this dimension N/A
4. Check if there is a CHANGELOG and whether it lists breaking changes for major versions
5. Look for a CONTRIBUTING.md — if contributors cannot find setup instructions they cannot help
6. Assess any public API surface: are types and parameters documented?
7. Identify anything a user would need to know that is not in the docs

Output: gaps in user-facing documentation ranked by impact on onboarding friction, with specific sections or files that need to be written or expanded.